The Augusta County Sheriff’s Office responded to a call about a baby not responding on April 8, 2023. There, authorities found an infant with bruises on its torso in the care of Nesselrodt. After 17 months of investigations, a grand jury indicted Nesselrodt for the murder.
According to court documents, Nesselrodt told investigators he had laid the baby down on a bobby pillow, scrolled on Facebook for several minutes and got up to use the restroom. Once he left the restroom, he found the baby unresponsive. Nesselrodt was the only caretaker in the home at the time.