RACINE — The county properly responded to reports of abuse in the home of a 2-year-old who later died, county officials said Tuesday.
The Racine County Human Services Department issued a summary of its own activities, paired with an announcement by Racine County Executive Bill McReynolds that the case was properly handled. A state investigation of the case is pending.
The written summary is comprised of information from county records about the Human Services Department’s contact with Brian’s family during the summer. It outlines the department’s response to four reports made about the family in July, August and September, as follows:
— In the first report, made on July 23, someone said there was “a lot of traffic in and out of the house,†and described someone pulling on the arm of Hawes’ 7-year-old son to get him to go upstairs. The information was secondhand and did not indicate a child had suffered physical injury.
“This report was considered informational, because nothing it contained described a situation that required (Child Protective Services) intervention,†the summary stated.
— Another report came in on Aug. 25, reporting the older child had been locked in his room and that there was physical abuse to the children. The caller also said they had seen drug paraphernalia in the home. CPS then opened an investigation.
CPS went to the home unannounced on Aug. 26 and met with the mother’s boyfriend, believed to be Jessie Rodriguez, the man charged with Brian’s death. The boys were wearing shorts and no shirts and the investigator saw no injuries and they did not appear to be malnourished. Two days later, the investigator spoke with Tisa Hawes, the boys’ mother, who did not admit to hitting her children. She expressed an interest in accessing services and said she was starting counseling.
— On Sept. 6 a third report was made to HSD after-hours staff saying that the children were being locked in their rooms, that they were pulled away from windows after talking with neighbors and that they had been hit. Racine police went to the home on Sept. 7 and reported the children appeared to be all right.
— A fourth report came in on Sept. 17 indicating a third party had seen similar conditions to those previously reported. “Nothing in the Sept. 17 report indicated that either child had been recently injured or that the children were in immediate danger,†the summary said. Five days later, on Sept. 22, HSD opened a new investigation regarding the circumstances of Brian’s death.
McReynolds said the county had been statutorily prohibited from answering any questions about HSD’s involvement with this case until this summary report had been completed, and that it was further limited to only commenting on things contained within the report.
“We are confident that, especially given the limitations of state law, and given the information available to the Human Services Department, the case was properly handled,†McReynolds said.
Now, the department has asked the state to expedite its investigation into the case. The state routinely investigates deaths of children, according to a county release. That investigation will likely include a review of department records and interviews with staff that worked on the case, said Debra Jossart, director of the Racine County Human Services Department.
Officials said they could not answer questions about what kind of counseling or assistance Tisa Hawes was interested in receiving or what kinds of answers the older boy, who is now in protective custody, gave when asked about discipline in the home.
District Attorney Michael Nieskes said there were apparently none of the kinds of signs of abuse that would have triggered further action by CPS.
“We need to see physical injury substantiated,†he said. “Medical reports, observations, the parent or child (making a statement). None of those things were done.â€
Without that, there was little the authorities could do, he said.
“The conversations I’ve had with the staff, they indicate as far as this case, the indicators weren’t there,†McReynolds said.
At the press conference about the summary, the boy’s grandmother questioned its accuracy, asking why her calls to the agency in July were not included.
After the press conference, Nieskes and Director of Human Services Debra Jossart spoke with the woman. Nieskes said they reviewed phone logs from Human Services for July 12, a Saturday, the day the woman initially said she called, but found nothing. She later revised that date to Monday, July 14, but nothing was found for that day either, Nieskes and McReynolds said.