“No words can even begin to explain the pain I feel,” McKnight told Costanzo. “My heart is broken. I would do anything to bring my baby daughter back.”
Navaeah died Aug. 11, 2022, after she became unresponsive while sleeping in bed with McKnight and her father, James May IV, inside the couple’s First Street residence. The bedroom was littered with drugs and paraphernalia, and an autopsy revealed the presence of fentanyl in Navaeah’s system at the time of her death. Her 16-month-old brother was also sickened by the drug, but survived.